If you love comforting fall desserts that warm up the soul, you'll adore this Apple Butter Pie Recipe. It’s perfect for cozy evenings when you want something rich yet surprisingly simple to pull together. This pie combines the deep, cinnamon-spiced goodness of apple butter with a creamy custard filling—something a bit different but irresistibly delicious every time.

Apple Butter Pie Recipe - Recipe Image — Apple Butter Pie, fall dessert recipes, cozy pie with apple butter, cinnamon apple pie, easy apple pie filling

Jump to:

Why You’ll Love This Apple Butter Pie Recipe
Ingredient Spotlight
Step-by-Step: How to Make It
Pro Tips
Variations & Substitutions
Make-Ahead, Storage & Freezing
Serving Ideas & Pairings
FAQs
Notes, Tools & Special Equipment
Printable Recipe 📖

❤

Why You’ll Love This Apple Butter Pie Recipe

I’ve found this pie hits the sweet spot between cozy and elegant, so it’s always a crowd-pleaser without fussing with a complicated filling. The flavors blend beautifully, and the texture is creamy but not heavy. Plus, it uses apple butter, which adds a deep, spiced richness you don’t often get in pies.

Texture you want: Smooth, custardy with a tender, flaky crust
Flavor that pops: Warm spices blended with luscious apple butter
Everyday ingredients: Pantry staples combined with simple pie dough
Works for any night: Easy enough for weeknights, special enough for guests

Ingredient Spotlight

The magic here is in using good-quality apple butter, fresh warm spices, and a well-chilled pie crust. I like to use spelt pie crust for a nutty flavor, but regular all-purpose crust works just fine too. Heavy cream gives that rich custard feel, while brown sugar deepens the sweet notes without overpowering.

Apple Butter: Look for a thick, aromatic apple butter—preferably homemade or a trusted brand for the best depth of flavor.
Spelt Pie Crust: Its subtle nuttiness complements the apple butter but you can swap with your favorite pie dough.
Spices: Freshly grated nutmeg and ground cinnamon are a must; fresh spices bring a warmer, more vibrant flavor than preground.

Seasonality & Sourcing

Apple butter shines best in the cooler months, especially fall when apples are at their peak and spice cravings hit. If you can't find fresh apple butter locally, you’ll often see quality jars at farmers’ markets or specialty stores during harvest season. Using seasonal spices like cinnamon and nutmeg keeps this pie smelling like a warm kitchen in autumn. For budget-friendly options, prepare your own apple butter at home ahead of time or pick up a store brand with minimal additives.

Step-by-Step: How to Make It

Step 1 — Prep & Preheat

Start by rolling your pie dough into an 11-inch circle to fit a 9-inch pie plate. You'll want the dough to press nicely into the plate’s sides and bottom with no air pockets—this helps avoid sogginess. Don’t forget to prick the bottom with a fork all over to allow steam to escape during blind baking. Pop it into the freezer for 15 minutes; chilling the dough firm before baking stops shrinking and keeps those edges crisp. While the crust chills, preheat your oven to 375ºF and position racks in the middle and lower spots for even heat circulation.

Step 2 — Cook & Build Flavor

Place the chilled crust on the lower oven rack lined with parchment and weighted with pie weights (I usually use dry beans from my pantry). Bake for 20 minutes to set that base, then remove the weights and parchment and bake an additional 5 minutes on the same rack. This two-step ensures a golden crust that won't get soggy when the filling goes in. Reduce your oven temperature to 325ºF. Whisk apple butter, eggs, cream, brown sugar, and spices together until smooth and creamy. Pour this luscious filling into your pie shell and slide it onto the middle rack. Bake for 45–55 minutes until the edges puff up and the center jiggles slightly – perfect custard warning! Overbaking? The filling firming beyond 180ºF will start to dry out; underbaking leaves it too loose, so keep that thermometer handy for the best results.

Step 3 — Finish & Rest

After baking, transfer the pie to a wire rack to cool. Don’t rush this part—letting the pie rest for at least six hours in the fridge finishes setting the filling perfectly, balancing creamy texture with pie-like firmness. I usually prepare this the day before serving, which makes life easier and flavors even better. You’ll notice how the spices bloom more as the pie chills. Serve chilled or at room temp depending on your preference.

Troubleshooting Apple Butter Pie Recipe

If your pie feels too dry, check that your oven doesn’t run hot and watch the baking time—too long will rob moisture. For a bland pie, don’t skip fresh spices or reduce the sugar too much; the apple butter needs that sweet-spice balance to shine. Soggy crust? Blind bake carefully with weights, and cool the crust well before adding filling—warm pie dough plus wet filling is the biggest culprit. If your filling jiggles too much after baking, simply let it chill longer in the fridge to firm up fully.

💡

Pro Tips

I've learned the hard way that temperature and timing make or break this Apple Butter Pie Recipe. Keeping your pie crust cold before baking helps avoid shrinkage and ensures flakiness. Also, don’t rush the chilling after baking: that wait is when the filling truly firms and the flavors meld.

Heat control: Use an oven thermometer to avoid overbaking custard; slow and steady low heat works best.
Timing window: Aim to serve pie after chilling at least six hours to get the best slice and flavor.
Make-ahead move: Bake the pie a day ahead; it tastes even better after resting overnight.
Avoid this pitfall: Don’t skip blind baking—wet filling plus raw dough means a soggy, sad crust.

Variations & Substitutions

If you want to put your own spin on the Apple Butter Pie Recipe, try adding a splash of bourbon or vanilla extract into the filling for extra warmth. To lighten it up, swap heavy cream for half-and-half, though it will be less custardy. For a gluten-free crust, a store-bought blend or almond flour crust pairs nicely, just watch the baking time. You can also stir in chopped toasted walnuts or pecans for a crunchy contrast.

Great Debates

There’s always the pie debate: spelt crust or all-purpose flour? I find spelt brings a subtle earthiness that complements apple butter beautifully, but all-purpose flour is a reliable, well-loved classic with a crisp flake. Another is whether to use butter or shortening in your crust; butter gives amazing flavor, but shortening can make it flakier. For this recipe, I lean toward butter for that comforting flavor boost.

Make-Ahead, Storage & Freezing

This Apple Butter Pie Recipe keeps beautifully covered in the fridge for up to four days. Use an airtight container or wrap tightly with plastic wrap to prevent it from drying out or absorbing fridge odors. If you want to freeze it, do so before baking the custard filling—freeze the blind-baked crust wrapped well, and the custard filling separately in an airtight container. Thaw overnight in the fridge and bake fresh for best texture. Avoid freezing the fully baked pie as custard pies can get watery or grainy after thawing.

Yield & Conversions

This recipe yields one 9-inch pie, comfortably serving 8 slices. To scale up for a larger gathering, you can double everything and bake in a 10- or 11-inch pie pan, adjusting bake times slightly longer to accommodate the volume. For half the yield, halve all ingredients and use a smaller 6- or 7-inch pie dish, baking time reduced to about 30–40 minutes on the custard bake. For metric fans, 1¾ cups apple butter is 470 grams, and 1 cup heavy cream is about 226 grams.

Serving Ideas & Pairings

Serve slices of this pie just as they are or add a scoop of vanilla ice cream for a classic touch. A dollop of lightly whipped cream with a sprinkle of cinnamon elevates it perfectly. For something cozy, pair with a hot cup of chai tea or spiced coffee. If you want a savory contrast, a sharp cheddar cheese on the side surprisingly complements the sweet-spiced custard beautifully.

FAQs

Can I use canned apple butter for this recipe?

Absolutely! Good-quality canned apple butter works well. Just choose a brand without added preservatives or artificial flavors for the best taste.

How do I prevent the crust from getting soggy?

Blind bake the pie crust with weights to firm it up before adding filling, and chill the crust well before baking to create a barrier against sogginess.

Can I make this pie dairy-free?

You can substitute heavy cream with coconut cream or a plant-based cream alternative, although the texture will be a bit different and less custardy.

How long does the pie need to chill?

Plan on at least 6 hours in the fridge, but overnight resting is ideal to let the filling set fully and deepen the flavors.

Notes, Tools & Special Equipment

Use a 9-inch pie plate for this recipe to ensure proper depth and even cooking. An oven thermometer helps maintain the right temperature, especially important for custard pies. I recommend a large mixing bowl and a whisk for smooth filling, but a hand mixer works if you want to make things extra easy. For the crust, rolling pins with thickness guides make sure you get consistent dough thickness every time. Lastly, pie weights or dry beans for blind baking are essential to keep the crust edges from shrinking.

Printable Recipe 📖